Is Grit Enough? Why Your Environment Matters More Than Your Willpower

Hosted by Eric Mazur · Guest: Angela Duckworth · Produced by Allison Villaseñor
November 19, 2026

Is Grit Enough? Why Your Environment Matters More Than Your Willpower

In this episode of Social Learning Amplified, host Eric Mazur sits down with Angela Duckworth, author of the bestseller Grit and the forthcoming Situated: Find the People and Places That Bring Out Your Best. Duckworth, who once took physics with Mazur as an undergraduate, explains why decades of research on self-control led her to look beyond the individual and toward the people, places, and objects that shape our thoughts and actions.

In this episode of Social Learning Amplified, host Eric Mazur sits down with Angela Duckworth, author of the bestseller Grit and the forthcoming Situated: Find the People and Places That Bring Out Your Best. Duckworth, who once took physics with Mazur as an undergraduate, explains why decades of research on self-control led her to look beyond the individual and toward the people, places, and objects that shape our thoughts and actions. Together they explore her framework of situation, thoughts, and response, and how it helps educators reconcile productive struggle with removing unnecessary friction. They discuss why great achievers rarely succeed alone, what social learning looks like in her own classroom, and why going device-free has been her most effective tactical decision. They also tackle generative AI and cognitive offloading, and why banning it is not the answer.

‍

Eric: Thank you for joining us today for this episode of the Social Learning Amplified podcast series. I'm your host, Eric Mazur, and today we are joined by Angela Duckworth, the Rosalie and Egbert Chang Professor at the University of Pennsylvania and co-director of Penn Wharton Behavior Change for Good Initiative. A 2013 MacArthur fellow, Angela served as an advisor to the World Bank, the NBA, the NFL, and Fortune 500 CEOs. Before a distinguished academic career, she worked as a McKinsey consultant and as a public school math and science teacher in New York City, San Francisco, and Philadelphia. Her TEDx talk is one of the most viewed of all time, and she's the author of the massive number one New York Times bestseller, Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance. She joins us today to discuss her highly anticipated and soon-to-be-released second book, Situated: Find the People and Places That Bring Out Your Best. Angela, thank you so much for being here today.

Angela: Eric, I’m so excited for our conversation!

Eric: Me too! Your new book, Situated, shifts the lens outward, but led you to realize that internal resolve wasn't the whole story. What prompted you to write Situated?

Angela: You know, Eric, when I got started studying the psychology of world-class achievers, it's true. I wanted to look inside their heads. I mean, I wanted to know, like, how do they see the world in a way that is different from the rest of us? And what are their internal goals? You know, how do they think about practice? And I do think the answers to those questions are very important, because world-class achievers don't have all the same beliefs as the rest of us. They do see the world differently. They do formulate their goals differently, organize them differently, and they have attitudes towards practice that I think are uncommon. But when you take a paragon of grit like Michael Phelps and you widen the aperture, and just as you said, Eric, when you look outside of their head, like, who is standing behind Michael Phelps? Oh, there's his mother, Debbie, and his sisters, Whitney and Hilary. Oh, who's that guy over there? Yeah, that's his coach, Bob Bowman, likely the greatest swimming coach in history, not only in the United States, but across the world. You think to yourself, oh, okay. Well, what about the team? Yeah. Did that matter? Oh, absolutely. And I think all of those situational factors that are outside the head, actually not only are imperative for achieving goals, they actually

Eric: Well, I love this shift because in my own classes recently, I've become deeply interested in self-determination theory, measuring how we can design environments that maximize autonomy, competence, and relatedness to foster intrinsic motivation for learning. And I think in this new era of generative AI, fostering that intrinsic motivation is more critical than ever. If a student's environment doesn't support their self-determination, the temptation to engage in cognitive offloading, to just, you know, hand their thinking over to a chatbot, is incredibly high and irresistible, in a sense. In your research for Situated, did you look at how environment directly impacts self-determination and how we can design environments that buffer against the temptation to sort of mentally check out?

Angela: Well, Eric, you know that this is not our first conversation. And you also remember being my professor when I was taking physics as an undergraduate. And I will tell you that there was no cognitive offloading in your class. It was a great class. And I learned more than I thought I could ever be capable of learning. But it was hard. And I think one of the great challenges of modern life is that increasingly technology creates an environment, creates a situation that may not bring out our long-term best. What happened to me in your class is that with support, I was able to learn. You know, physics is very intimidating. And that's, of course, the class that you were teaching me, and I did what I didn't think was possible. And now, of course, we're surrounded by AI tools, for example, that can do the physics for us. I think that the question of intrinsic motivation is exactly the place to start, because that's inside your head, right? Do you think of yourself as a competent person? Do you feel connected to the people around you, like truly one with the group? And then, of course, do you feel competent? Those are the three dimensions, as you know, of intrinsic motivation, which is delineated in Edward Deci's and Richard Ryan's self-determination theory. Again, a topic we've talked about. But what I love about this question is that it explains how what's inside your head is related to what's outside your head. In your class, I genuinely felt competent. I came in with a lot of insecurity. Is it because I'm a girl? Is it because physics and math are intimidating? I don't know, but in your class, I developed a sense of mastery. I developed a sense of confidence in physics. Did I feel connected? I did, because somehow the culture, and I know you went on to make your classes more and more peer-oriented, more and more about teams learning, which is like the real world. But somehow in your physics class, I didn't feel like it was at all cutthroat. I didn't feel like it was survival of the fittest. Everybody that I remember taking that class with was genuinely trying to help everybody else learn very, very hard stuff. And so we did feel like we belonged. We felt connected and related. And I may have forgotten to mention autonomy as the third component of intrinsic motivation, as you say. And that is feeling like you have choice and control. And I think there in that class, I did feel like I had choices, that I had control. Of course, there were exam things I didn't have choice over. But somehow you communicated a culture where, like, you know, the students were in charge of their own learning. And I think that question, and hopefully my answer, connects the situation, the environment, the class, the culture, the professor, to what's inside the head. How intrinsically motivated do I feel? So I think my desire to explore the outside situation in this book is deeply connected, in a way, a natural extension of trying to understand factors like intrinsic motivation, which very much characterize gritty people. And I have data on that.

‍Eric: I was still giving exams then. That's such a long time ago. I know. In the book you outline what I think is a brilliant framework, the framework of three boxes: situation, thoughts, response. And you point out that most traditional advice tells people to build willpower and discipline, focusing entirely on that third box, the response, which is a mistake. And instead, you advocate for creating a frictionless path where high performers consciously manipulate the objects and spaces within their arm's reach to sort of eliminate friction. What does research actually say about how well pure willpower works? And could you share an example of what a truly frictionless environment looks like?

‍Angela: Well, I've been studying willpower and self-control more broadly since my very first day of graduate school. I went to graduate school when I was 32. Now I'm 56, right? So it's more than two decades, and I will tell you that the research definitively, certainly within the last 20 years, has kind of upended the idea that willpower is good. It's not to say that willpower is bad, you know, to have control over your impulses, to be able to directly modulate them, to force yourself not [transcript gap] to put yourself in situations, you know, surrounded by people and with objects in view that encourage spontaneously the kind of positive, optimistic thoughts like, oh my gosh, you know what? This problem set is interesting. You know what? This is important. I can see how this is connected to the larger goals of my life, and I think I can do it. And I have an idea of exactly what to try next. Now imagine a person in your class who has those positive, optimistic thoughts because of the situation, because they're sitting next to students who are on a team that they've gotten to know, that they share, you know, some personal experiences with, not just kind of classmates, but friends. Like you have an inspiring teacher, you know, your parents are encouraging you. You're not in a room filled with televisions, cell phones, and tablets, but actually, you're at a clear desk with, you know, things to write on. Like, I think that is the situation that encourages the thoughts. Then the thoughts bring forth the effort without forcing yourself, and research shows, but I think even just a moment of personal reflection affirms, that starting with the situation is dramatically more efficient, dramatically more reliable, and dramatically less exhausting.

Eric: I'd like to stick with that idea of friction, and not in the physics sense. Don't worry. Here, because in a sense, this idea of the three boxes and the frictionless space points to a massive paradox that we're kind of facing in education right now, because in the age of AI, the path to a completed assignment, which I would say is the response box, has become completely frictionless, right? Your student can bypass the thoughts box entirely with a single prompt. But as educators, you and I are both educators, we know that deep learning requires what you and your colleagues, social psychologists, call desirable difficulties, a certain amount of cognitive friction, in that middle box. Right. So when I introduced peer instruction, the goal was to actually add productive friction to the classroom, to force students to argue, defend ideas, and grapple with concepts socially. So how do we reconcile these two ideas? How do we use your framework? It seems like a contradiction. Friction bad, friction good. How do we use your framework to remove the logistical friction that leads to student burnout while intentionally injecting the cognitive and maybe social friction that forces students to stay in that thoughts box and think for themselves?

Angela: Well, I'm going to use an analogy because I think it's kind of obvious when you think of, for example, an athlete in training. Now if you're trying to get to be a faster swimmer, for example, right, you need to work at your edge, right? So you need to actually practice swimming. You have to swim laps and you have to swim them harder and faster and with more refined technique than you did before. So that is friction. Of course, it's physical friction through the water, but there is a lot of cognitive friction, because the key to becoming a great athlete is not just physical. Crucially, you develop more sophisticated mental representations. And anybody who's ever watched a World Cup soccer game, or call it football if you like, or an Olympic event, kind of intuits that, like, wow, these athletes are not only physically well developed, but they have these incredibly sophisticated mental representations. They can predict what's going to come next. They adapt accordingly. And that's what makes them so great. So you need cognitive friction and physical friction to become a great athlete. However, if you interview great athletes, they try to minimize friction in every other aspect. So, for example, I interviewed for the book one of the greatest triathletes of all time. And if you speak to triathletes, some would argue that he is simply the greatest triathlete of all time, Alistair Brownlee. And he, I will tell you, is as gritty as they come. But he removed friction. What do I mean? He literally bought a house, his first house, so that it would be close to the running trails and to the places where he was going to train and swim. He made sure that he laid out his workout clothes the night before. He laid out his sneakers. I mean, he was reducing friction everywhere he could. Now let's take that into the realm that the rest of us live in, because most of us are not athletes. Yes, you have to have desirable difficulty. Absolutely. You have to practice at your edge, whatever it is you want to do: writing, teaching, learning to be a better cook. But why don't you remove all the unnecessary friction? I mean, make it easier to do hard things.

Eric: I like your analogy of, you know, the physical friction, because it's not that different after all. Yeah. What I found one of the most interesting frameworks in Situated is this idea of, I think you call it contextual personality, the idea that we have, like, modes, personality modes, like angry Angela, but also sort of our character, behaviors, and habits change drastically depending on the people around us, not just on how we arrange our physical environment, but the people. And now you've also written about the power of peer learning, the idea that who we learn with shapes how much we learn, something that resonates very strongly with my work. So how does situated thinking change what we should ask of schools, teachers, and even leaders of educational institutions?

‍Angela: Well, let me say what I think is the fundamental paradigm-shifting insight. Instead of making your way through the world and just thinking like, I'm Angela, here's Angela's resume, like, here are the things that Angela has accomplished, you think of yourself in context. You know, there's nothing shameful or embarrassing to say that Angela wrote a book with, like, not just Angela and her editors and her researchers, but her daughters and her husband. Oh, wait, her mother-in-law. So when you make your way through the world, it's your name on the book. It's your name on your resume. But who does anything really great by themselves? I'm coming to the belief, whether it's like Isaac Newton or Thomas Edison or, you know, whoever you can think of as a hero, when you really look at the story in its totality, nobody learns or does anything on their own. It's almost always in collaboration. So I think in some ways the deepest paradigm shift that we can make, but it's very difficult, is to not wake up in the morning and just think like, hi, I'm Angela, hello, I'm Eric, but like, I am Eric, married to this person, father of that person, collaborator of this person, mentor of this person, mentee of that person. So this dependency on other people, I think in some ways in our current culture is discouraged, right? Like you should do things on your own, like, don't rely or depend or weigh on other people. But in other cultures it's not only respected but admired to think of yourself as part of a larger organism. And I'm Chinese, and that is certainly, I think, part of an Asian tradition, to think of the individual embedded in their context.

Eric: Yet, and maybe more so in the Western world and in other cultures, we tend to celebrate the individual and the individual accomplishments. All that you said, in a sense, hits at the exact heart of our series, Social Learning Amplified, if you think of higher education in particular, but in general, you know, we often isolate students, expecting them to study alone, to take high-stakes exams alone, and... Right. What's your SAT score? What's your transcript GPA? Right. And somehow find their inner grit. Right. But your... places that isolation is an environmental failure, so to speak. So how can the university instructors and school instructors who are listening to this podcast stop demanding individual willpower and instead use the power of peer groups and social learning to, in a sense, you know, pull the best performance out of their students?

‍Angela: And one of the things that I changed when I started, you know, really embracing the idea of social learning, was that this precious time that these undergraduates have given me, you know, they have very busy schedules. And to take this elective means they're not taking some other class, they're not doing some other activity. And my first thought when I signed up to do this was that every moment of this precious time should be me, you know, being a great professor, giving fantastic PowerPoint presentations, being as energetic as possible. What I've decided to do is actually devote the first 15 minutes of class to team discussion. That means I'm not saying anything. In fact, the students leave the room. They go outside, unless it's raining. They sit in groups of about four, and they have a conversation prompt that I have crafted to complement the topic of the next lecture. And they take turns leading this group. So everybody takes a turn being a leader of the team. And then, of course, there's only four people. So usually around three turns of being leader of your team over the course of the semester. And I had a lot of ambivalence about doing that, Eric, because I thought, like, wow, this tuition is a lot. You're kind of not paying to be around, like, other 19-year-olds, right? Weren't you paying to be with me? And it's the most popular part of my class. I mean, students at the end say, I'm going to be in touch with these teammates at my 25th reunion, like, I learned more from them than I learned from you. And I think that's a victory, actually. But it was so hard for me as a professor to say that I would take 15 minutes of the class and not be in front of the students holding forth. So that's just one small way in which I'm trying to really embrace the idea that these students can teach each other much more powerfully than if they sit passively with a pen in their hand, waiting for me to say something wise.

Eric: Absolutely. I love that idea. And I want to look back to the theme of your book. I remember as I started reading, and I think we all sort of unconsciously do that with any book we read, you know, because most books have some autobiographical components. So I just have to ask, is there a situation in your own life you redesigned, and what happened when you did that?

Angela: I'll tell you about something I didn't write about in the book, but I've just thought about it, actually, since, you know, finishing the last edit. So when I think about this book, Eric, I mean, it was so hard to write. I mean, I know authors say that, but I was so... the situation was not a great situation. Like, I somehow was not getting the support I needed. And it felt very weak to me to complain about it, to look outside of myself for the solution. I just thought, Eric, if I worked harder, you know, like even insomnia, I was like, if I just try harder to go to sleep, like, I'll do it. And what I realized is, I mean, this is completely... I needed more editorial help, which... I also needed to see somebody for... And I climbed out of that hole. I also changed where I worked. I mean, one of the things I think that was not helpful was I wrote this book mostly in my own house. It was during the pandemic at the beginning. And then I just decided to take a sabbatical, and I thought it would be more efficient if I just, like, woke up in my pajamas and I started working on the book. And then if I were still in my pajamas, I could just go to bed like that. And working seven days a week in my house without just being with people was not a good situation. So I think in a lot of ways I had situational obstacles that, even though I was writing a book about the situation, I was blind to for a very long time. And it's only when I changed the situation, not myself, but my situation, that things began to... true. And I don't think I've ever had a time in my life, professionally or personally, that was as hard as that time. And as you can tell, I'm not in that state anymore. And that's because I'm in a better situation.

Eric: I should have read your book before I started writing my textbook. Do you know how long that took? Oh, I signed a contract for five years. It took 22 years. Yes, writing is difficult. You know, I just have to ask you one more thing for the stressed K through 12 teacher or the exhausted university professor listening today who wants to change their classroom environment tomorrow. I'm sure that you've thought about this because you're an educator, too. What is sort of one small, you know, manageable environmental tweak you can make to reduce friction and bring out the best in students?

‍Angela: Well, let me say this. I think the single most effective hack for improving engagement in a classroom has been going device-free. In my classroom, you cannot use your phone, you cannot use a tablet, and you cannot use your laptop. And I say it very clearly on the syllabus, and I show them data on the very first day to explain why I have this policy. I show them the famous brain drain study that shows that the closer the phone, the lower your IQ score. I explained to them that I'm going to do everything I can, including team meetings, to make this engaging, but I also tell them that I can't beat TikTok. Like, there's just no way. So I say, if you don't like that policy, then I respect that, but then you can't take the class, and I enforce it. I mean, it becomes a strong cultural norm, but it's also baked into the... way, if we see you on a device, you are going to get points... It's just that simple. So we call it like an old-school classroom. The students joke that this is what it would be like to be in the 1980s. I'm like, yeah, you're too young to know what the 1980s were like, but here you go. This is pretty much it. So I would say going tech-free in the classroom was the single best tactical decision I've made about the physical environment of my classroom. And I have one question for you. But then, promise? You talked about cognitive offloading and AI, I wanted to probe that, because I think all of your colleagues, or nearly all of your colleagues at Harvard, certainly most, if not all, of mine at the University of Pennsylvania, have ambivalence about AI. But they sure as heck are using it. So how do you reconcile that paradox, Eric? Can you just say what it looks like, ideally, optimally, in the future for learners? Because I don't think the answer is like, never open ChatGPT.

Eric: Absolutely not. I'm quite sure that our students, when they graduate, just like we ourselves, are using it for more and more tasks. They will have to use it in their work. So if we don't prepare them for that, I think that would be really bad. I think the real problem is that we're in a time of future change, and we don't even know yet exactly what it is doing to us. Yes. That's the real problem, right? We need to understand first how we can use it, how we are using it, what it is doing to us, what this is doing to our brains, before we can take any informed decision about how to best use it in a [transcript gap]. I am certainly on the scale more towards building it into the curriculum, into the instruction. But they have to be responsible. They have to be transparent. I want them to disclose their AI use, and I make it clear that there is no... And I rely more and more on oral... justification... instruction. Yeah. Instead of just, like, banning it, which is naive, by the way. I have data suggesting that if you are an educator and you think you can ban AI use, you're kidding yourself. Like, when we survey students, Well, Angela, thank you so much for sharing your wisdom, your insights, your journey with us today. It's a powerful reminder that we don't have to carry the entire weight of grit on our shoulders. You know, sometimes we simply need to change the room we're standing in. So on behalf of all of our listeners, thank you for joining us.

Angela: Thank you, thank you.

Eric: You can find Angela Duckworth's brilliant new book, Situated: Find the People and Places That Bring Out Your Best, at Simon and Schuster, Amazon, and bookstores everywhere. To find more episodes of our Social Learning Amplified podcast, visit perusall.com/social-learning-amplified and make sure to subscribe so you never miss an episode. I look forward to welcoming you back next time.

Stay up-to-date!

Subscribe to our newsletter.